Butt Plugs

Lovense Hush 2 1″ Butt Plug – Black by Lovense product image

Shop Butt Plugs with 493 live products at Phareros. Typical pricing in this section: $4.55 to $270.00. Use filters for Body Safe, Material, and Brand to narrow quickly.

Explore Phareros’ Butt Plugs & Anal Products — a curated collection of teardrop-shaped plugs, tapered trainers, and anal accessories crafted in body-safe silicone, latex, and smooth acrylic. Designed to stimulate the perineum and surrounding areas, these versatile toys range from beginner-friendly slim profiles to more substantial options for experienced users.

Butt Plugs Buying Guide

Use quick filters for budget, body-safe materials, and shipping speed, then compare your top 2 to 3 picks before checkout.

Compare before you buy

More buying help

Compare popular options

New to this? Read our guide: Anal Training: working up comfortably →Body-Safe Materials →Cleaning & Caring for Your Toys →
◯ Body-safe onlyOne tap to show only non-porous, body-safe materials. What’s that? →

Showing 25–48 of 493 results

📚 New: Anal Training: Working Up Comfortably

Top picks in Butt Plugs

Best-selling picks in Butt Plugs — compare 2 to 3 before you check out.

Quick compare

ProductBody SafeMaterialPriceRatingStock
Lovense Hush 2 1″ Butt Plug – BlackTop supplier rankYesSilicone$119.003.8 (29)In stockView
Lovense Hush 2 1.5″ Butt Plug – BlackTop supplier rankYesSilicone Original price was: $130.00.Current price is: $119.00.3.8 (29)In stockView
Lovense Hush 2 1.75″ Butt Plug – BlackTop supplier rankYesSilicone Original price was: $130.00.Current price is: $119.00.2.9 (57)In stockView
Lovense Hush 2 2.25″ Butt Plug – BlackPopular pickYes— Original price was: $130.00.Current price is: $119.00.2.8 (45)In stockView
Hot Octopuss PleX with Flex – BlackPopular pickYesSilicone Original price was: $100.00.Current price is: $99.00.—In stockView
b-Vibe Snug & Tug Weighted Silicone & Penis Ring – 128 g BlackPopular pickYesSilicone Original price was: $55.00.Current price is: $49.50.—In stockView

Shop by intent

Showing 25–48 of 493 results

Featured in our Kits

Products like these are hand-picked for The Anal Starter Kit and Prostate Play Kit and Anal Progression Kit — curated sets that ship discreetly.

Butt Plugs in All Sizes, Vibrating and Static in Metal, Crystal, Rubber, Latex, Glass and more.

Best Sellers and More in Butt Plugs

More in Butt Plugs

Common questions

How much do butt plugs cost?
Across the 436 currently in stock, prices run from $4.55 to $270.00, with a median of about $25.99. Shipping is free on US orders over $49.
What are butt plugs usually made of?
Of the butt plugs we have classified, the most common materials are Silicone (58%), Metal (15%), Glass (9%), PVC (5%), Stainless Steel (5%). About 11% are porous materials such as PVC, TPE or rubber. Porous materials cannot be fully sterilised, so they suit trying a shape rather than long-term use, and we say so on the product page rather than hiding it.
How do you rate butt plugs for body safety?
We score every product 0-100 on what it is actually made of, its brand track record and real demand. 422 of these butt plugs carry a score, and the median is 78/100. The score is published even when it is unflattering — see how we score at /phareros-score/.
How many brands of butt plugs do you carry?
We currently stock 436 butt plugs from 113 different brands, so the range spans budget novelties through to body-safe heirloom pieces.
Are butt plugs shipped discreetly?
Yes. Everything ships in plain packaging with nothing on the outside indicating what is inside, and the billing descriptor is discreet too.