Best Butt Plugs for Budget
How these were picked: Cheapest in-stock first. We show each pick’s Phareros Score alongside the price so you can see what the saving costs you. Chosen from the 446 butt plugs in stock today.
- Fantasia Pleasure Plug Mini – Orchid $4.55 cheapest in this category
- Glams Xchange Round Gem – Small $5.25 cheapest in this category
- Glams Xchange Heart Gem – Small $5.25 cheapest in this category
- Boundless Slim Plug $6.29 cheapest in this category
- Boundless 2X Teardrop Plug $6.29 cheapest in this category
- Boundless Teardrop Plug $6.29 cheapest in this category
- Camtoyz Lucio Anal Plug – Blue $6.30 cheapest in this category
- Fantasia Pleasure Plug Small – Azure $6.79 cheapest in this category
Counted from live stock on 21 October 2026. Scores come from what each item is actually made of, its brand record and real demand — published even when unflattering. How the Phareros Score works.