Black Friday: 30% off pjur · 20% off Arcwave, Cousins Group, Fifty Shades, Happy Rabbit, ROMP, We-Vibe, Wicked & WomanizerShop the Sale →

Best Butt Plugs for Budget: Comparison Guide

Best Butt Plugs for Budget

How these were picked: Cheapest in-stock first. We show each pick’s Phareros Score alongside the price so you can see what the saving costs you. Chosen from the 405 butt plugs in stock today.

  1. Fantasia Pleasure Plug Mini – Orchid $4.55 cheapest in this category
  2. Glams Xchange Heart Gem – Small $5.25 cheapest in this category
  3. Boundless Slim Plug $6.29 cheapest in this category
  4. Boundless 2X Teardrop Plug $6.29 cheapest in this category
  5. Boundless Teardrop Plug $6.29 cheapest in this category
  6. Camtoyz Lucio Anal Plug – Blue $6.30 cheapest in this category
  7. Fantasia Pleasure Plug Small – Azure $6.79 cheapest in this category
  8. Glams Xchange Heart Gem – Medium $6.93 cheapest in this category

Counted from live stock on 20 November 2026. Scores come from what each item is actually made of, its brand record and real demand — published even when unflattering. How the Phareros Score works.

Browse all 467 butt plugs →

Don't forget these essentials

Free Domestic shipping

On all orders over $49. All other orders ship for $7.49

100% Secure Checkout

PayPal / MasterCard / Visa / American Express / Discover / Venmo / Apple Pay / Google Pay