Black Friday: 30% off pjur · 20% off Arcwave, Cousins Group, Fifty Shades, Happy Rabbit, ROMP, We-Vibe, Wicked & WomanizerShop the Sale →

Best Butt Plugs for Body Safe: Comparison Guide

Best Butt Plugs for Body Safety

How these were picked: Non-porous materials only (silicone, glass, steel, ABS), ranked by Phareros Score. Porous items are excluded rather than ranked low. Chosen from the 405 butt plugs in stock today.

  1. B-Mine Butties – Silicone Butt Plug with Heart Base – Pink $22.49 Silicone, non-porous
  2. Rookie Beginners Starter Silicone Plug $22.49 Silicone, non-porous
  3. b-Vibe Slide Silicone Butt Plug $26.99 Silicone, non-porous
  4. b-Vibe Dart Silicone Anal Plug $26.99 Silicone, non-porous
  5. b-Vibe Thumb Silicone Prostate Plug $26.99 Silicone, non-porous
  6. b-Vibe Butties Bulb Tapered Prostate Plug – Blue $27.00 Silicone, non-porous
  7. b-Vibe 4″ Vibing Plug $31.49 Silicone, non-porous
  8. b-Vibe Butties Bounce Beaded Tapered Plug – Blue $31.50 Silicone, non-porous

Counted from live stock on 20 November 2026. Scores come from what each item is actually made of, its brand record and real demand — published even when unflattering. How the Phareros Score works.

Browse all 467 butt plugs →

Don't forget these essentials

Free Domestic shipping

On all orders over $49. All other orders ship for $7.49

100% Secure Checkout

PayPal / MasterCard / Visa / American Express / Discover / Venmo / Apple Pay / Google Pay